Today we started getting calls and emails from customers asking when the best day is to send out their email marketing campaigns saying “Happy Thanksgiving” to their customers.

Obviously one of the benefits of email marketing is that your message can be timely, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you should wait until the absolute last second to hit send.

There are primarily two schools of thoughts when it comes to email marketing strategy on this topic.

1. First Mover Advantage
While this actual term typically refers to a company gaining a competitive advantage by entering a market segment first (see Wikipedia on First-Mover Advantage), I like to use it on a more micro level as it applies in this case. If you want your customers to get their first “Happy Thanksgiving” email from you, then go ahead and send it early. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with launching your email marketing campaign before the actual holiday is upon us. If you think that waiting will make your customers say “Yet another email wishing me happy thanksgiving” then go ahead and send it early.

2. Timeliness Is Everything
My birthday is on June 5. But, if someone were to call me up on May 26 and say “Happy Birthday Rob!”, I’d probably think they’re crazy. I mean, nice gesture, but come on? That same sort of methodology applies to your email marketing campaigns around Thanksgiving. Just about everyone realizes that email is an instant technology (that’s one of the key benefits over traditional snail mail!). So, you may make your customers wonder why you jumped the gun on pressing send on your email so early.

In my opinion, no matter which option you choose for your email marketing strategy, the important thing is to realize that your customers will appreciate the gesture. So, in this case, there may be no wrong answer, just two variations of the right email marketing strategy.

Go ahead and adopt whatever you think will work best for your audience, but don’t spend too much time worrying about the exact timing. After all, while I thought the person who wished me happy birthday in May was a little bit nuts, I still appreciated the gesture (and, heck, it may be the only birthday wish I remember because I’m even writing about it now!).